How to Find a Good Voice Teacher
​When All Of Us Say We Are Good​​

---

Some Truths Of Our Profession

• "The teaching of singing can be practiced in any country without a certificate of proficiency..." 

• "Any teacher can, by luck, produce one or two good voices..."
• "The cheapest voice teacher is not necessarily the best bargain..."  Gloria Bennett 

​So what makes a voice teacher qualified?

Pro Tip:  Find a teacher whose students end up where you want to go

THE ROOT ISSUE:
​University voice programs are generally geared to producing performers, but need an extensive vocal pedagogy track to produce voice teachers

For those seeking singing lessons, this information is critical to know because those coming out of university voice programs have had some introduction to the mechanics of the voice, but likely have had simple, topical training in teaching or voice pedagogy without much meat in terms of diagnosis and resolution of vocal issues.  And after graduation, a good many of them end up giving voice lessons.  Although it is slowly changing, it is a problem in our industry.  The problem for the student is that the effects of working with a well-meaning-but-untrained voice teacher can be hard to correct.  Once ingrained, acquired habits can be hard to rewire.​​

A voice teacher in the truest sense is one whose focus is on the technical work of building the voice - and those who fit this definition can be hard to find.  Traditionally, universities have been inclined to hire professors with a performing background versus those with a pedagogy background.  While performers can offer valuable insight into performing and coaching repertoire, they might not have had the type of training to become a teacher of voice.  More often, the teacher you find inside or outside of academia is most oriented to working on songs and coaching repertoire than doing the technical work of building a voice from the ground up. It is not their fault because this is the long-standing tradition of how they and their teachers and their teachers' teachers were trained.
​ 
The good news is that sports performance science and vocology have been paving the way for newer, evidence-based ways to teach voice. Singing is a motor skill comparable to learning a sport. When compared to tennis, for example, it is understandable that you can improve somewhat by playing game after game, but you will only truly improve when you break the individual skills down, working on your forehand, backhand, overall strength, aerobic conditioning, etc.  Songs are like tennis matches - no two are exactly alike.  To improve your singing, it will take the more methodical approach of repeated patterns to build the numerous skills and coordination of singing which can then be applied to a song. ​​

Our Qualifications

What makes a good voice teacher?

You want to find the person who has invested in becoming a teacher by having an advanced certificate or degree in vocal pedagogy.  Next best would be to find a teacher who has a voice degree from a school that offers an in-depth teacher training program in which they have taken courses.  In either case, even with a degree this person must be someone who seeks continuing voice pedagogy education and professional development after graduation to remain current in the field.  Either way, it takes a lengthy period of study, observation, and supervised teaching to become a qualified voice teacher.
​
​Becoming a good voice teacher takes this type of commitment to pedagogy training plus a good ear plus good instincts to become adept at the diagnosis and re-coordination of vocal issues. This all can take time to develop.  And, understand that even for a good teacher, it can take 2-4 years to build a voice from the ground up.  As well, it is important to recognize that with a student, one can lead a horse to water….Also, it is a completely different ballgame when a high-level student walks through the door with their vocal groundwork basically done thanks to prior teaching.  These types of students have already shown the needed motivation and discipline to tackle the hard vocal issues, so for the new teacher focusing on repertoire and artistry is a bit of an easier street to travel.  There is not much more thrilling, though, than finding diamonds in the mud.

All in all, these are things you need to know when looking for a prospective teacher. 
​
Be sure to consider what you want and how this teacher's results and interests align with your goals. 

Where do their students end up and is that where you want to go?

Luke Randazzo wins National First Place, Upper High School Classical Tenor, Baritone, Bass!!!!!!!

---

Three advance to National Semi-Finals!!!

Three Regional Winners
Schmidt Vocal Competition!!

Many university professors contribute much to research

Many university professors might be more on the research than the applied side of voice and focus on advancing the understanding of voice training and function.  The work of these academics is a joy for me to interpret and apply to my own teaching. 

Luis, Luke, Joseph, Josh, Amogh, Eva, Carmen, Norah
Eight NATS National Quarterfinalists 2022!!!

Luke and Jonah
NATS National Quarterfinalists 2021

Fall 2021 Prizewinners

Luke Randazzo wins 2nd place and $2,000, Matinee Musicale, 2021, with online voice lessons

---

Luis will be attending MSM on a $30K scholarship and will be in the studio of legendary bass-baritone, James Morris.

A GREAT ARTICLE ABOUT CHOOSING A VOICE TEACHER

Although it was written in 1994, the issues are the same today...​

"More is demanded of the professional singer today than ever before. Not only must you have the voice but also you must have the brains. Not only must you have a good musical instrument, but you must use it for the expression of the thoughts and emotions that define and motivate humanity. 

You cannot learn to sing from a book or a record. It takes personal interaction. You need a trained ear listening to you, encouraging you when you make progress and alerting you to bad habits that inhibit your progress. 

It is also important to find a teacher who really understands the basic vocal mechanisms, and can effectively educate the student. My gripe with so many of the teachers is that they just sit and play scales and don't really explain how to get the most benefit from each scale. Today's teachers vocalize, they exercise, but they don't educate their students. 

A teacher must be honest, and must be able to demonstrate the technique, and be able to show the control of their own voice. Never study with a teacher who is chronically hoarse. The teaching and the technique should be very natural. While proper technique may be difficult to learn, it should not make you feel physically uncomfortable. If a technique takes a great deal of physical effort to demonstrate, then it cannot be correct. This is one area where the old saying, "Those that can't do...teach," does not apply. If your teacher does not have a beautiful vocal instrument, beware. Even though the goal of study is not to imitate the teacher, a voice teacher should be able to demonstrate the validity of the methods he or she is teaching. 

The job of a voice teacher is to teach you to control, and thereby free the voice to develop to its full potential. A teacher should not impose a style for you, for style and flair come from within. When you are vocally free to express you own feelings, your unique style will develop naturally.  ​(Cont...)​

Why do so many reputable teachers hold so many different opinions, whether they teach privately or in music schools? The main reason is that there is no single authority whose judgment on singing is universally accepted. Unlike any other branch of study, the teaching of singing can be practiced in any country without a certificate of proficiency. An untrained teacher can set up practice in any country without a certificate of proficiency. An untrained teacher can set up practice, begin to publicize themselves, and develop a large group of unlucky students. Even a bad teacher can set up a practice, begin to publicize themselves, and develop a large group of unlucky students. Even a bad teacher might occasionally find a student with an exceptional voice, which, with careful study, might have developed into an outstanding instrument. But by improper training, the voice may be damaged or irreparably harmed. Such self-appointed authorities probably never passed an exam and never had to explain what right they had to teach. 

People come to teaching by different roads. Some teachers have planned to teach from the outset and use their good and bad experiences from their years becoming or trying to become singers to help others. Some start teaching after more or less successful careers. Some take up teaching because they never realized their own ambitions. Some teachers try to build up a large clientele by developing a stable of associates, that is, student teachers who are still studying themselves. These "associates," at best, parrot the method of the master teacher. At worst, they damage the unwary students they come in contact with, for they lack the experience to oversee the building of a voice. 

Singers must examine their motives very carefully before deciding to pursue a career as a teacher. The general attitude, a patient temperament, is very important. The danger with some active singers who teach is that they sometimes compete with their students. The teacher has to feel love for the student, like a responsible parent, not like a baby sitter who dislikes children and only takes the job for the money.  ​(Cont...)

This brings us to the financial motive. A reputable teacher should have asked themselves this question: "Am I in this profession for its own sake, or only for the income I can derive from it?" The best motive for teaching is the love of voice and the joy of developing a voice to its fullest potential. 

Apart from the ability to teach, it is critical to hear objectively as well as subjectively as singers normally do, to be able to diagnose what is heard. The skills are to recognize how a student is producing their sound, identify the things that inhibit the sound, and apply the correct remedy. In other words, the diagnosis is like that of a doctor's, who looks at the symptoms for a clue to the cause of the trouble. 

Many good singers are not able to teach because they lack this ability, while some have a dual gift for singing and teaching. Coaches who are often unable to sing well themselves often lack the knack for teaching. Dedicated professional teachers are interested in teaching even during a period of successful activity in their own careers. If they possess the talent of listening critically, they may continue to learn much and apply it to their own singing. Good teachers, too, can learn from teaching.  ​(Cont...)

An objective way to judge a teacher is to hear his or her students at certain intervals. Any teacher can, by luck, produce one or two good voices, but the reputable teacher gives something to all students that makes them progress at their own optimum pace. "High notes created in the shortest time... technically faulty singing will be corrected... develop great vocal power...etc." An honest teacher could never promise so much. Students who hear these outlandish claims should be on guard. Such dishonest teachers will never admit their inability to keep their promises. Instead, the fault of failure is laid on the student's head. "I'm sorry to have to tell you this, but you have a physical defect that will never allow you to become a singer." Don't believe it. Unless a throat specialist tells you that you have a serious throat problem, you can sing!

Before I paint the perfect voice teacher, I would like to stress that teaching is hard work, a commitment which takes years. A teacher gives the advice gained from years of study and hard work, and earns every penny he or she gets. You don't get something for nothing in this world, and if you are benefiting from your voice lessons, then you should be glad to pay for them. Nothing worth having in this world is easy or cheap. And a career as a singer is a thrilling experience that only one person in a thousand may be able to have. 

Don't measure your teacher by the dollar, however. The cheapest voice teacher is not necessarily the best bargain. Likewise, a voice cannot be bought by the pound, so that even the most expensive teacher may not be the one for you. The expression, "Penny wise and pound foolish," really applies when choosing a voice teacher. Find the one for your needs and stick with them!" 

*— pp.103-105 from Breaking Through: From Rock to Opera, the Basic Technique of Voice (Milwaukee, Hal Leonard, 1994) by Gloria Bennett.

​(End)